Amanda So ’28
Staff Writer
I looked down from my safe haven, the balcony of Green Beach at Claremont McKenna, onto a mosh pit of girls in variations of the same corset from Amazon, like a uniform that I was all too familiar with from the countless TikToks I had scrolled through while getting ready for that night. Meanwhile, I was covered in blood, head to toe, my white Victorian nightgown stained crimson. Lizzie Borden would have been proud.
For a holiday designed to let people express their individuality, the corset costumes are almost indistinguishable from one another. While I appreciate the style of these corsets and how they make some women feel sexually empowered, I wonder whether we have begun to prioritize performing desirability over genuine creative expression. I cannot help but long for a time when sexy Halloween costumes were actual costumes, and not just vessels to show off the female form.
Sexy Halloween costumes are far from new. Leg Avenue, the brand that popularized the quintessential Y2K sexy Halloween costumes sold in plastic bags, has dominated college girls’ Halloween lookbooks for years. These costumes feature intricate lace paneling, exaggerated fit-and-flare silhouettes, and accessories that bring their respective characters to life. Like today’s Amazon corsets, Leg Avenue costumes showed off the female form, but they also had details that made them look like specific costumes at first glance.
Take their 2000s rendition of Cinderella: a baby-blue and white lace-paneled corset minidress, a white faux-fur capelet with a flowing mesh train, an embellished black choker, white satin opera gloves, and white lace thigh-highs. This Cinderella was coquettish, campy, and sweetly sexy. Today’s Cinderella, however, might sport a blue Amazon corset, a miniskirt, and perhaps a ribbon choker to pay homage to the original character. Swap the corset’s color and the accessories, and suddenly she can be Snow White, Aurora, or Tiana. I suspect this growing homogeneity helps explain the resurgence of vintage Leg Avenue costumes on TikTok. The girls yearn for distinct costumes again.
An Amazon corset perfectly mirrors society’s current beauty standards: a tiny waist, boobs up to the moon, and enough discomfort to make breathing feel optional. However, this brazenly sexy silhouette raises a question: does looking desirable necessarily mean expressing desire?
This brings me to prolific feminist philosopher and writer Audre Lorde. In her landmark essay Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power, she distinguishes superficial sexual stimulation from genuine erotic power. For Lorde, true eroticism is rooted in joy, creativity, and self-knowledge, rather than the mere appearance of sexiness. In her essay, she wrote, “The erotic cannot be felt secondhand,” meaning that genuine erotic fulfillment must come from within, rather than from satisfying someone else’s expectations of pleasure and desire. Through this lens, the Amazon corset represents something beyond a Halloween costume: it is a standardized performance of feminine desirability. When the same silhouette dominates countless costumes, I wonder whether we’re dressing to embody our own fantasies or simply reproducing what we’ve been taught makes us attractive.
To be clear, my issue does not lie with the women who wear these corset costumes. My issue is with the algorithm that convinced us all to buy one. TikTok’s algorithm exposes women to the same costume trends, making certain silhouettes seem like the default way to look attractive on Halloween. Why on earth wouldn’t you buy the $20 Amazon corset after seeing countless women praised for their bodies while wearing it online? Halloween supposedly celebrates individuality, yet our costumes increasingly reflect a collective ideal of feminine desirability. Having a plethora of costumes to choose from does not necessarily mean we have endless opportunities for self-expression.
I am grateful that, generally, American women in college have the freedom to wear what we want and feel sexy and empowered while doing so. Women’s choices should not be policed, and the validity of sexual expression should not be placed on a scale of the creativity of their Halloween costumes. Still, Halloween is my favorite holiday, and I would like to see a bit more experimentation among the 5C student body. My wish does not involve abandoning sexy costumes — desire, playfulness, theatricality, and self-expression can coexist. So much of my joy comes from temporarily embodying someone else, even if that occasionally involves lots of blood and scar wax.
Note to men: a red T-shirt with a large “M” on it is not a Mario costume. Do better.



